Will Republican Senate incumbents not win in exactly one nominating election in the 2026 cycle?

Two confirmed Republican Senate primary defeats—Bill Cassidy in Louisiana and John Cornyn in Texas—have already occurred in the 2026 cycle, establishing a baseline of two incumbents denied renomination. Trader consensus around three or four total losses reflects expectations of one or two additional upsets in remaining primaries, fueled by strong conservative challenges in several states and patterns of intra-party opposition to incumbents viewed as insufficiently aligned with party priorities. Open seats from retirements such as Joni Ernst in Iowa and Cynthia Lummis in Wyoming reduce the pool of vulnerable incumbents, while races like Susan Collins in Maine feature more general-election dynamics than primary threats. The distribution of probabilities underscores the impact of these early results alongside uncertainty over whether further primary challenges will succeed before the cycle concludes.

View this market on Polymarket →